In with the Devil: A Fallen Hero, a Serial Killer, and a Dangerous Bargain for Redemption

Product Information

But I think, when you do realise how deeply organic it is, that there's something driving these people, that gets to the point where they really cannot control themselves.”

His offer was a simple, but dangerous one: befriend suspected serial killer Larry Hall and get him to confess to at least two more murders out of the 19 they believed he was responsible for, and he could walk free. El problema es que Keene resulta muy desagradable y parece ser un vendehumos. Con haberlo introducido en los dos últimos capítulos habría bastado. After five months undercover, Keene managed to gain Hall's confidence, and he started to ask Hall about his crimes with the suggestion that he'd remain friends with him even if he confessed to several alleged killings.

In his book, Keene explained that taking part in the operation allowed him to spend five years with his father, who passed away in 2004. Levin's research really revealed how Hall's meek doughboy facade belied a cunning intelligence capable of the terrible crimes of which he was accused. I couldn't stop thinking that the "wannabe" role he played with the local cops allowed him to hide in plain sight. For Keene's part, he's definitely a flawed hero but one that seems genuine in seeing the error of his ways. You definitely root for him. Just a few months into his sentence, Keene was approached by the prosecutor who put him behind bars. He had convicted a man named Larry Hall for abducting and killing a fifteen-year-old. Although Hall was suspected of killing nineteen other young women, there was a chance he could still be released on appeal. If Keene could get him to confess to two murders, there would be no doubt about Hall's guilt. In return, Keene would get an unconditional release from prison. But he could also get killed. Hall’s bizarre grooming was a key element that tied him to many of his suspected victims. Their abductions coincided with “reenactments” at nearby historic battlefields. A dedicated Civil War buff, Hall traveled throughout the country to portray a Union foot soldier and even appeared as a period extra in two films. His muttonchops, emulating those of a Union general, were intended to make his face look as authentic as his uniform and rifle. It was 2008, and investigative journalist Hillel Levin had been talking to a serial killer Larry Hall, who was convicted for the 1993 rape and murder of a 15-year-old girl, Jessica Roach, and suspected of killing up to 30 other young women. Hall’s first alleged victim – 14-year-old Dean Marie Pyle Peters – disappeared in Michigan when Hall was just a teen.

The show – which is executive produced by Keene – suggests a disturbing premise: both Jimmy and Larry are tied together through their obsession with women. One is a womaniser using sex to ignore childhood trauma; the other is an incel who could never get girls until he killed them.

Where is everyone now?

Levin's portraits of both Keene and Hall are thoughtful and thorough. Obviously the arcs of each man's story are grossly different, but Levin weaves through both in a way that helps explain without excusing the worst behaviors of either. The U.S. Attorney and FBI rewarded Keene’s efforts in 1996 with early release and a completely clean record. Officials have been unable to find the remains of any of Hall’s additional victims. However, based on the new evidence Keene uncovered, Larry Hall's appeal was denied. Hall remains in prison and has confessed to over twenty murders during his incarceration. [9] He is serving a life sentence without parole in Butner, North Carolina, [12] and officials believe he may be responsible for up to 40 murders. [6] Media coverage [ edit ] In reality, Keene recalls in his memoir saying, “Hey, you look cool. Do you know where I can find the library?” Hall explained where it was, and then asked: “You think I’m cool?” Keene replied that he did, making Hall laugh. Hall went every day at 2:30, he said, to read the papers, and Keene would make sure to go at the same time. Eventually, Hall invited Keene to breakfast with him and his friends – known by other inmates as the “baby killers”. People probably wouldn't understand the mounting pressure, that kettle's ready to boil over at any time, ya know, and it just felt good to unload on the guy," James Keene told Dateline. "I'm disappointed I didn't wait another day or two at least. I should have waited a few more days." However, Keene pointed out that the confessions and information he got from Hall led to the reopening of several cold cases that may have involved the alleged serial killer. "I did a good deed, and I did a lot of good things. And that's where I feel the redemption comes in. I've done something good for the things that I did wrong." The information Keene got out of Hall was instrumental in Hall losing his appeal and remaining in prison. He decided to finally let out the disgust and anger toward Hall that he had been bottling up ever since Hall had opened up about some of his brutal crimes against young women. "I went across to his cell over there," recalled Keene. "The repulsiveness I felt about him throughout the whole time I had to stay being his friend and the disdain and dislike I had for him, that I thought it was good for me to unload on him and tell him what I really thought of him and who he really was. I said, 'You know, I'm gonna be going home tomorrow, Larry,' and I said, 'You're a crazy killer,' and I started calling him everything you can think of."